Rare and Valuable U.S. Pennies

Dive into the fascinating history of U.S. pennies, and uncover which ones might be worth more than their face value. From the early Large cents to the iconic Lincoln cent, each series has its own unique history and potential value.

If you believe your penny collection contains some valuable coins, Coinfully offers free, no-obligation appraisals. Reach out to us or fill out our appraisal form to discover the value of your collection.

Get an appraisal

Instant value guide

Flowing Hair Large Cents (1793)

The Flowing Hair Large cents were among the first pennies minted in the United States. These coins are highly collectible due to their historical significance and limited mintage. Key varieties include:

1793 Flowing Hair Chain cent: The first U.S. penny, featuring a chain design on the reverse.
1793 Flowing Hair Wreath cent: A rare variety with a wreath on the reverse.

These coins are highly sought after by collectors and often fetch high prices at auction.

Get an appraisal

Liberty Cap Large Cents (1793–1796)

The Liberty Cap Large cents, designed by Joseph Wright, featured a Liberty head with a cap on the obverse. Collectors often look for:

1794 Liberty Cap Large cent: A key date for collectors due to its rarity and historical significance.
1796 Liberty Cap Large cent: The final year of this design, making it a crucial piece for any collection.

These coins are cherished for their detailed design and connection to early American history.

Get an appraisal

Draped Bust Large Cents (1796–1807)

Draped Bust Large cents were designed by Robert Scot and are known for their elegant portrayal of Liberty. Notable coins in this series include:

Get an appraisal

1796 Draped Bust Large cent: A rare and valuable coin due to its low mintage.
1804 Draped Bust Large cent: Highly collectible, especially in higher grades.

These large cents are prized by collectors for their classic design and historical importance.

Indian Head Pennies (1859–1909)

The Indian Head pennies, designed by James Barton Longacre, are among the most iconic U.S. coins. Key dates and varieties include:

1877 Indian Head penny: A key date with low mintage, making it highly sought after by collectors.
1909-S Indian Head penny: The final year of the Indian Head series and a rare find.

These pennies are popular among collectors for their beautiful design and historical significance.

Detailed close-up of an assorted pile of pennies, highlighting the diversity in wear and patina of each coin.

A collection of Morgan Silver Dollars, highlighting the coin's return with its historic design and modern minting techniques.

Lincoln Wheat Pennies (1909–1958)

The Lincoln Wheat pennies, introduced to commemorate the 100th anniversary of Abraham Lincoln's birth, are some of the most widely collected U.S. coins. Notable coins in this series include:

1909-S VDB Lincoln penny: The first year of issue with the designer's initials on the reverse, making it highly valuable.
1943 Steel Wheat penny: Produced during World War II, these pennies are unique due to their steel composition.

These pennies are prized for their historical connection to Lincoln and their widespread collectibility.

Additional Information for Coin Collectors

Get an appraisal

Understanding mintmarks, key dates, and the historical context of your pennies is crucial for identifying valuable coins. At Coinfully, we provide expert appraisals to help you uncover the true value of your collection. For a free appraisal of any U.S. pennies, reach out to us today.

Get Started Today!

Get an appraisal

Ready to see how much your U.S. pennies are worth? It’s easy to get started with Coinfully. Simply request a free appraisal, and our experts will handle the rest. With no obligation to sell, you have nothing to lose.

Free Appraisal With No Obligation To Sell

Take the first step toward selling your silver coins by getting a free appraisal today. Our process is designed to be transparent, convenient, and stress-free, giving you the confidence to sell when you’re ready.

At Coinfully, we’re committed to helping you get the most for your silver coins—all from the comfort of your home.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

How do I know I’m getting a fair price for my pennies?

At Coinfully, we pride ourselves on transparency. Our appraisals are based on the current market value of your pennies, including their metal content and numismatic value. We provide a detailed breakdown of how we determine your offer so that you can be fully informed and confident in the price you receive.

Is my shipment insured when I send my pennies to Coinfully?

Yes, we provide full insurance coverage for your shipment. Whether you’re sending Flowing Hair pennies, Indian Head pennies, or Lincoln cents, your coins are insured throughout the entire shipping process, ensuring that your valuable items are protected and safe.

What types of pennies does Coinfully buy?

We buy all types of U.S. pennies, including Flowing Hair, Liberty Cap, Draped Bust, Indian Head, and Lincoln pennies, and other collectible pennies. Whether your pennies are valuable for their metal content or their collectibility, we’re interested in making you a competitive offer.

What if I’m not ready to sell after receiving an appraisal?

There’s no obligation to sell your pennies after receiving an appraisal from Coinfully. We provide a free, no-pressure appraisal service to help you understand the value of your coins. You can choose to sell when you’re ready, with no pressure from us.

View Our Key Services